Human Reproduction and Birth Control
Checking and Charting Fertility Sign 1: Thermal Shift Patterns (BBT)
Methods of ABC (Artificial Birth Control)
Methods of Natural Birth Control
Advantages of NFP and Charting
Moral Significance of Birth Control Methods
Comparative Analysis of Birth Control Methods (chart)
* Listed in descending order of effectiveness for perfect use
* Effectiveness rate = 100%-failure rate, which is not actually the rate of non-pregnancy, but rather the rate of non-pregnancy where pregnancy would have occurred without the method in use
* Sources
METHOD |
Effectiveness (Pearl Index) for Perfect Use ( "Method Failure") |
Effectiveness (Pearl Index) for Actual Use ("User Failure") |
Health Side-effects and Risks |
Moral Concerns |
Cost |
Additional Pros |
Additional Cons |
Removal of Ovaries |
100% |
100% |
Subsequent pregnancy impossible; Health risks associated with surgery |
None |
None |
||
Castration |
100% |
100% |
Subsequent intercourse and pregnancy impossible; Health risks associated with surgery |
Self-mutilation |
None |
Achieves 100% birth control effectiveness only by eliminating intercourse altogether |
|
Continual Abstinence |
100% |
100% |
None |
None |
None |
None |
Achieves 100% birth control effectiveness only by eliminating intercourse altogether |
Combination Pill |
99.9% |
97% |
Probable decreased sex drive, vaginal dryness; Possible circulatory problems, vision problems, heavy bleeding, weight gain, gallstones, benign liver tumors, headache, depression, sleep disorders, skin conditions, increased risk of certain cancers |
Abortifacent mechanism 2-50% of time (depending on woman) + Dishonest expression of total self-giving |
$300/year |
Regularizes cycles; possible decreased risk of some cancers and osteoporosis and rheumatoid arthritis |
Have to take a pill daily |
Progestin Implants (Norplant) |
99.9% |
99.9% |
Requires insertion and removal surgery; Possible weight gain, acne, decreased sex drive, cardiovascular problems, scarring of skin, osteoporosis, and problems with future fertility; Prolonged infertility (50% of women do not resume cycles by 6 months after removal; 25% by one year after removal). |
Installation + regular follow-up visits to doctor |
None |
None |
|
Vasectomy (Male Sterilization) |
99.85% |
99.85% |
Difficult to reverse (45-60% of couples achieve pregnancy after a reversal); slight risks of decreased sexual drive, prostate cancer, and abnormal autoimmune response aggravated by the body attacking the sperm cells that seep into the body; Bleeding in about 5% of men and inflammatory response to sperm leakage |
Dishonest expression of total self-giving + self-mutilation |
None |
None |
|
Depo-Provera Injections |
99.7% |
99.7% |
Bleeding may be heavier and more irregular or painful; May accelerate bone loss in young women; Possible weight gain, decreased dex drive, acne, cardiovascular problems, and future problems with fertility; Not available to women over 35, smokers, and women with liver or cardiovascular problems |
Possible abortifacent mechanism + Dishonest expression of total self-giving |
None |
None |
|
99.7% |
97.2% (88-90% rates sometimes cited due to intentional violation of rules, and therefore do not reflect ineffectiveness of the method) |
None |
None |
$20 for textbook |
Requires more training and understanding than ABC methods; Impractical for those desiring casual sex or incapable of periodic abstinence (25-35%); No protection against STDs; Requires abstinence during woman's period of peak sexual drive |
||
Tubal Ligation (Female Sterilization) |
99.6% |
99.6% |
Difficult to reverse; Possible hormonal disturbances leading to mood swings, irregular bleeding, and sexual difficulties, sometimes correctable only by total hysterectomies; seriously increases the risk of an ectopic pregnancy (very dangerous and always kills child); Minor complications from the surgery (6%); Major complications from the surgery (0.8- 2%); Post-tubal ligation syndrome (long-term complications) (22%- 37%); More severe cramps, heavier, longer periods, dysfunctional uterine bleeding, pain with intercourse, and pelvic pain or pressure (for which 43% have subsequent gynecological treatment) |
Dishonest expression of total self-giving + self-mutilation |
None |
None |
|
Abortion |
99%+ |
99%+ |
Possible permanent sterilization, infections, perforation of the uterus, emotional effects including guilt, grief, and shame, pain during intercourse, decreased sexual drive, damage to uterus and/or cervix, and even death |
Takes life of developing human being |
None |
None |
|
Intra-Uterine Device (IUD) |
98.5% |
98% |
Frequent heavy bleeding; Pregnancies which occur are likely to tubal (dangerous); Body sometimes expels device without woman's awareness, leaving her vulnerable to unplanned pregnancy; Presently difficult to obtain in U.S.A. due to lawsuits |
Causes abortion 98-98.5% of time + Dishonest expression of total self-giving |
None |
None |
|
Old (pre-1975) High-Dose Pill |
No longer available due to severe side-effects |
Abortifacent mechanism 1-12% of time; Dishonest expression of total self-giving |
None |
None |
|||
"Morning-After" Pill (Preven) |
75% |
Minimal for one-time use |
None |
Not a good method for repeated or long-term use |
|||
98% |
98% |
None |
None |
None (saves ~$500 per 6 months of breastfeeding instead of bottle feeding) |
Breastfeeding good for mother-child bond and child's psychological and physiological health; Provides child with valuable lifelong immunities to allergies and diseases |
Impractical for those desiring casual sex; No protection against STDs; Not a long-term method because it is useable only during breastfeeding periods |
|
Male Condom |
97% |
88% |
Woman's immune system is not exposed to man's sperm which can cause problems if a pregnancy is attempted later; not useable for those with allergies to latex; some spermicides linked to birth defects |
Free if you find provider; otherwise about $.50 per act of intercourse |
Protects against STDs; May prolong pleasure of intercourse by delaying ejaculation |
Aesthetically revolting; decreases sensation; for proper use, foreplay and afterward embracing must be interrupted; Fairly low effectiveness in actual practice |
|
"Mini Pill" (progestin only) |
97% |
93% |
Possible decreased sex drive, circulatory problems, vision problems, heavy bleeding, weight gain, gallstones, benign liver tumors, headache, depression, sleep disorders, skin conditions, increased risk of certain cancers |
Abortifacent mechanism 93-97% of time; Dishonest expression of total self-giving |
None |
None |
|
Withdrawal (Coitus Interruptus) |
96% |
81% |
None |
None |
Difficult to practice due to high level of self-control required; Very low effectiveness in actual practice |
||
96% |
User failure greater than for NFP, as signs are harder to interpret |
None |
None |
$20 for textbook |
Requires more training and understanding than ABC methods; Requires longer abstinence than NFP and not as effective; No protection against STDs; Requires abstinence during woman's period of peak sexual drive |
||
Female Condom |
95% |
79% |
Woman's immune system is not exposed to man's sperm which can cause problems if a pregnancy is attempted later; not useable for those with allergies to latex |
Protects against STDs; May prolong pleasure of intercourse by delaying ejaculation |
Aesthetically revolting; decreases sensation; for proper use, foreplay and afterward embracing must be interrupted; Extremely low effectiveness in actual practice |
||
Diaphragm (w/ spermicides) |
94% |
82% |
Commonly tied to urinary tract infections; Some spermicides linked to birth defects |
None |
None |
||
Spermicidal Cremes and Foams |
94% |
79% |
Some spermicides linked to birth defects |
None |
None |
||
94% |
88% |
None |
Dishonest expression of total self-giving when using ABC during fertile period |
Whatever costs are associated with the barrier method + $20 for textbook |
Requires more training and understanding than ABC methods; Impractical for those desiring casual sex or incapable of periodic abstinence (25-35%); No protection against STDs; Requires abstinence during woman's period of peak sexual drive |
||
Vaginal Sponges |
91% |
82% |
Some spermicides linked to birth defects |
None |
None |
||
Cervical Cap (w/ spermicides) |
91% |
82% |
Can cause cervical abnormalities; Necessary to interrupt foreplay to insert the device and apply spermicide; Some spermicides linked to birth defects |
None |
None |
||
Calendar/ Rhythm Method (Ogino-Knaus) |
87% |
80% |
None |
None |
None of side-effects and risks of ABC |
Requires long periods of abstinence (as much as the whole cycle if under stress); Relatively low effectiveness |
|
No method |
15% |
15% |
None |
Irresponsible use of sex without concern for provision for possible children |
None |
None of side-effects and risks of ABC |
High risk of unplanned pregnancy, with accompanying worries; Impractical for those desiring casual sex; No protection against STDs |
Post-coital Douche |
less than 15% |
less than 15% |
Linked to increase in pelvic inflammatory disease and ectopic pregnancy |
None |
Ineffective--actually pushes sperm deeper |
Checking and Charting Fertility Sign 1: Thermal Rise Patterns (Basal Body Temperature, or BBT)
Checking and Charting Fertility Sign 2: Cervical Fluid
Checking and Charting Fertility Sign 3: Cervical Position
Other Fertility Signs
Rules of natural birth control for ovulatory periods)
Rules for Identification of Preovulatory Infertile Stage:
: The first five days of new cycle (regardless of length of menses) are safe from risk of pregnancy if there was obvious temperature rise 12-16 days earlier and the shortest cycle in the last year was 23-25 days (if the shortest cycle was 22 days, this becomes the First 4 days rule; if the shortest cycle was 26 days or longer, this becomes the First 6 days rule).
- For women with luteal phases longer than 16 days, Doering Rule is more appropriate.
: The interval of 12-16 days after a thermal rise is strong evidence that the bleeding observed is not mid-cycle or abnormal bleeding, but true menses. Since it is very unlikely for both ovulation to occur on or before Day 10 (first 5-day rule + 5 day maximum sperm lifespan) and for sperm to survive 5 days in menses or dry environment, this rule is reliable.
- Principle
- If any of a womans previous 12 cycles were 25 days or less, this rule becomes the First 3 days rule.
- If she has premenopausal symptoms, this rule is unreliable.
- If any of a womans previous 12 cycles were 25 days or less, this rule becomes the First 3 days rule.
- Women who claim pregnancy from sex during menses either had intercourse during a long period (day 6 or later) or during mid-cycle spotting, mistakenly assumed to be menses.
: unprotected sex after 6pm every dry day following menses are safe from risk of pregnancy. The end of the preovulatory infertile period (the last evening safe from risk of pregnancy) is the last dry day.
- Women with long cycles including presence of less-fertile (i.e. sticky) cervical fluid from the end of menstruation up to the appearance of fertile cervical fluid (creamy, eggwhite) as well as 5+ days of fertile cervical fluid, this rule may be applied even in the presence of less-fertile (i.e. sticky) cervical fluid.
- An especially useful rule for couples with short luteal periods (less than 10 days of temperatures over the coverline).
: While sperm can survive a maximum of 5 days in fertile cervical fluid, in a dry environment or in sticky, infertile cervical fluid, they cannot and the risk is almost negligible (arousal fluid cannot sustain sperm until fertile cervical fluid appears).
- Principle
Rules for Identification of Postovulatory Infertile Stage:
The following rules are each independent, and are arranged in order from most to least conservative (and, correspondingly, from most to least abstinence required). Unlike the above rules, which can all be used in any cycle, the applicability of rules R and K depends on the specific thermal shift pattern for a given cycle. In an example cycle, the three rules provided the following first safe-day (beginning of Phase III):
- Draw vertical line between days 2 and 3 after temperature rise and another between days 4 and 5 after Peak Day to demarcate the fertile and postovulatory infertile periods (if they do not coincide, be conservative and consider the line further to the right to be the true threshold of the postovulatory infertile period).
- This rule may be too (i.e. needlessly) conservative for all but those who absolutely cannot afford a pregnancy.
- A more conservative version of this rule, which Kippley calls Rule C, allows intercourse only if there is a "full shift," with all 3 temperatures at least .4oF above the LTL).
- If you have 10 or fewer days of elevated temperatures over the coverline, check if your temperature rise coincides with your peak day or occurs the day after. If so, you have a short luteal period, which makes implantation difficult and pregnancy unlikely. If not, you have a delayed response to progesterone, i.e. your body's BBT will not rise to reflect ovulation until several days later. If so, you should wait till the sustained temperature shift and count Rise-2-3 before resuming intercourse. A slightly more risky alternative to the added abstinence is to rely on the Billing's Method and determine end of fertile window by using the Peak Day + 4 Rule along with confirmation of no cervical fluid ("dry") and infertile cervical position.
- If sick, wait till third day without fever with sustained temperature over coverline.
- If you have a slow-rise pattern, wait till Temp Rise +4 day rather than +3 for extra safety.
- If you have a fall-back pattern, you should start the count to 3 again when the temperature returns above the coverline after then day 2 fall-back, necessitating an extra 2 days of abstinence (or, with slight risk, you can rely on the Billing's Method, i.e. determining end of fertile window by using the Peak Day + 4 Rule along with confirmation of infertile cervical position.
- Sticky fluid (instead of dry) is not a problem so long as wet cervical fluid has not reappeared during the four days after peak day (if it had, this would suggest that ovulation is still recent enough or soon forthcoming enough to make pregnancy possible). A reappearance of wet cervical fluid before a temperature rise is called a split peak or double patch or double peak and requires a restart of the PK-1-2-3-4 count.
- Another variant is the split dry-up: a peak day followed by 2-3 days of drying up, then one day only of sticky cervical fluid, then dry days again with an obvious temperature rise. If this is observed, label the single sticky day as ? and continue count, e.g. PK-1-2-?-3-4.
- Principle: If the temperature shift shows a medium-strong rise, a medium amount of time needs to be allowed for cervical fluid to dry up.
- If used with shaving, you should shave only one temperature, and that by no more than .1oF.
- Principle: If the temperature shift shows a very strong, decisive rise, less time needs to be allowed for cervical fluid to dry up.
- This rule often allows an extra safe day in those cycles where a sharp, strong temperature rise is observed.
- Developed by Drs. Doering and Vincent, who used the BBT condition alone and observed 99% effectiveness.
- If used with shaving, you should wait for Temp Rise +3 with the final three at least .4oF over the LTL and PK+2; or Temp Rise +2 with Full Shift and PK+3.
Basic NFP Guide for Ovulatory Period (Sample Cycle Chart)
Based on 32-day cycle with 20 days allowable intercourse (31% abstinence)
NBO = Needn't be observed
ENP = End of Next Period
Day |
Phase |
BBT and other Symptoms |
Cervival Fluid |
Cervical Position |
Chance Preg. |
STM to Avoid Preg |
STM to Conceive |
1 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
NBO until end of period |
Menses; NBO until end of period |
NBO before dry days begin |
0% |
Allowed- First 5 Days Rule |
Infertile period |
2 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
NBO until end of period |
Menses; NBO until end of period |
NBO before dry days begin |
0% |
Allowed- First 5 Days Rule |
Infertile period |
3 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
NBO until end of period |
Menses; NBO until end of period |
NBO before dry days begin |
0% |
Allowed- First 5 Days Rule |
Infertile period |
4 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
NBO until end of period |
Menses; NBO until end of period |
NBO before dry days begin |
0% |
Allowed- First 5 Days Rule |
Abstain 7days before exp. fertile cervical fluid to avoid sperm depletion |
5 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
NBO until end of period |
Menses; NBO until end of period |
NBO before dry days begin |
0% |
Allowed- First 5 Days Rule |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
6 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Dry |
Firm, Low, Closed, Nonwet (FLCN) |
0% |
Allowed- Dry Days Rule |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
7 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Dry |
Firm, Low, Closed, Nonwet (FLCN) |
0% |
Allowed- Dry Days Rule |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
8 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Dry |
Firm, Low, Closed, Nonwet (FLCN) |
0% |
Allowed- Dry Days Rule |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
9 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Dry |
Firm, Low, Closed, Nonwet (FLCN) |
0% |
Allowed- Dry Days Rule |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
10 |
I: Prevolulatory Infertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Sticky |
Med firmness, part-open, mid-height |
0% |
Abstain- in case new cycle is short or sperm survive till ovulation |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
11 |
II: Fertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Creamy-fertile |
Med firmness, part-open, mid-height |
0% |
Abstain- " |
Start intercourse every other day |
12 |
II: Fertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Creamy-fertile |
Med firmness, part-open, mid-height |
11%- sperm may survive in fluid till ovulation |
Abstain- " |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
13 |
II: Fertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Eggwhite- fertile |
Soft, High, Open, Wet |
15% |
Abstain- " |
Intercourse |
14 |
II: Fertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Eggwhite- fertile |
Soft, High, Open, Wet |
20% |
Abstain- " |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
15 |
II: Fertile Period |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Eggwhite- fertile |
Soft, High, Open, Wet |
26% |
Abstain- " |
Intercourse |
16 |
II: Ovulation (Very Fertile) |
Low (97.2-97.4) |
Eggwhite- fertile |
Soft, High, Open, Wet |
15% |
Abstain after first sign of completed ovulation in case of multiple ovulation |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
17 |
III: Fertile Period |
BBT high (97.7-98.1) Day 1 |
Soft, High, Open, Wet |
9%- Eggs still alive |
Abstain |
Intercourse |
|
18 |
III: Fertile Period |
BBT high (97.7-98.1) Day 2 |
Dry or creamy (PK+1) |
FLCN |
5%- Eggs still alive |
Abstain |
Abstain to avoid sperm depletion |
19 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile "Luteal" Phase |
BBT high (97.7-98.1) Day 3 |
Dry or sticky (PK+2) |
FLCN |
0%- Eggs dead |
1st safe day by Temp Rise+2- Abstain |
High BBT means ovulation has occurred and window passed |
20 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (PK+3) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Abstain |
Infertile period |
21 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (PK+4) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Abstain |
Infertile period |
22 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
First Safe Day by PK+4- Allowed |
Infertile period |
23 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
24 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
25 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
26 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
27 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
28 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
29 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
30 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
31 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
Infertile period |
32 |
III: Postovulatory Infertile " Luteal" Phase |
High (NBO until ENP) |
Dry or sticky (NBO until ENP) |
FLCN (NBO after 3rd high BBT until ENP) |
0% |
Allowed |
If BBT still high after 18 days and no menses, pregnancy almost certain |
2 rules of natural birth control for anovulatory periods (including breastfeeding)
: as long as 2-week BIP remains constant, unprotected sex is safe from risk of pregnancy. When it changes (a "patch" of different quality cervical fluid, e.g. sticky patched on dry, or S,C,&E patched on dry, you are considered fertile each day until the fourth evening after peak day (effectively the same as the Peak Day + 4 Rule). If patch is sticky without creamy or eggwhite, you are safe on PK+2 day, with a very minimal increased risk. Treat bleeding as a fertile day.
- Patch Rule
Billings Ovulation Method (Cervical Fluid Only)
Achieving pregnancy of a pre-selected gender